Criminal Cases in the Crown Courts

When reading up on the Crown Courts in the new edition of McNae's Law for Journalists;

http://www.amazon.co.uk/McNaes-Essential-Journalists-David-Banks/dp/0199556458/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1255010671&sr=8-1


McNae's Law for Journalists
I found one section on reporting on majority verdicts particularly interesting.

In Crown Court, a judge will initially advise a jury to arrive at a unanimous verdict on each charge however if the jury had 'retired' for at least two hours and ten minutes and has failed to reach a verdict, then the judge will rule that a majority verdict is acceptable for each charge.

Now if a defendant is convicted by a majority then it is unproblematic for the media to refer to the fact that it was by a majority decision. This is because it indicates that one or two people didn't agree with the guilty verdict, and to report this is regarded as fair to the defendant.

However the problems lie in regards to reporting when a defendant is acquitted by a majority vote. It is regarded as 'undesirable' to publish the fact that it was by a majority verdict as it indicated at least one member of the jury believed the defendant to be guilty.

If reported, such an suggestion leaves a stain on the defendant's character even though he or she was cleared of the charge.

This could prove to trip up many journalists who believe they were reporting a seemingly innocuous truth so it is definetely something to watch out for.

ITV Idol?

The Independent surely has the story of the day today.

Simon Cowell

The paper highlighted a rumor that Simon Cowell and retail tycoon Sir Philip Green are working on a bid to save the soon-to-be-doomed broadcaster ITV.

A channel full of repeats of Britain's Got Talent,The X-Factor and American Idol. Great stuff.

However it might not all be bad as we could soon see some exciting new programmes hitting the airways such as 'Trousers: How High is too High?' and 'Ten Essential Guidelines On How to Act Like a Prima Donna at Your Birthday Party' .

Unfortunately friends of the pair deny the rumors. Maybe they could start off small with a two man double act. Then maybe ITV could get some laughs for once.

Too sick to work?

David Cameron

The recent announcement by David Cameron to cut incapacity benefit to those deemed "fit enough to work" has been met with an understandably mixed reaction from the British public.

Cameron suggested bringing in a new test to determine whether individuals should be placed on job seekers allowance instead of incapacity benefit which would mean reducing their benefits by £25 a week.

There are 2.6 million incapacity benefit claimers in the UK and the Conservatives believes one in five are actually fit enough to work. That's about 400,000 people.

For one of the millions rightfully claiming benefits this will mean more stress as they have to go for more check ups and tests to determine whether they are actually unfit to work.

Some individuals will undoubtedly believe that if they are told they are fit enough to work, the jobs they are qualified to do just simply aren't there.

Anthony Phillips from Cambridge who stopped working a year ago from a heart condition said: "They should think about cutting their own wage packets before picking on the already poor." (BBC News)

Cases in the UK must be handled more personally and should take into account the whole picture of the claimant.

The Conservatives need to realise that their proposed system of ticking boxes and fulfilling criteria will lead to many people in the UK feeling like scroungers.

Letterman blackmail case

David Letterman
Last week, the U.S. chat show host David Letterman shockingly informed his viewers of his affairs with women who work on his late night show.

He made the revelation during a filming of his late show because he said he was being blackmailed by a former colleague attempting to extort $2 million from him.

As the UK media history has shown us, Letterman had several options available to him once he knew that someone was in a position to expose his wrong doings.

As with the 'royal' blackmail case last year, Letterman could have applied for an injunction preventing the newspapers from reporting his name. Even though once the case went to court anyone with access to the Internet and even the remotest knowledge of how to operate a search engine could have found out the name of the 'celebrity' embroiled in the scandal.

More recently this inadequacy of media law was once again exposed in the UK as the papers were banned from revealing the identity of a TV journalist who was involved in an extra-marital affair which resulted in a child.

In order to make the area of media law relating to the press banning publication of names more airtight the Internet needs to closely regulated. This is a totally separate issue and many feel this would never be entirely possible because of the scale of in the World Wide Web.

More importantly the Letterman case demonstrates that some celebrities are willing to stand up tall and admit they made mistakes, even if it takes a blackmail case for them to finally come clean.

Maybe its time some UK celebrities started to face the music as well.

Barmy Blaney's Blarney

Browsing the news websites this morning I stumbled across a fine example of a giant waste of time:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/8285954.stm

For those of you who didnt bother to click the link then basically a blogger called Donal Blaney managed to get a high court injunction preventing someone writing under his name over a fake twitter account. Some of the provocative tweets posts included:

“So the Iranians were lying all along. Time for the RAF to start practicing bunker bombing...”

“Now Obama, who the eurofederasts [sic] love, is happy to leave us to the mercy of the mad mullahs...”

All very amusing.

An equally effective, less time consuming and certainly less over-the-top solution may have been to email the nice people at twitter and ask them to take the account down.

In a shameless display of egotism Blaney then wrote on his blog that: "It is, as I have said in the media, the day the scales of justice were tipped back in favour of innocent victims".

Lets hope this doesnt set a precedent for overly sensitive drama queens wasting legal time and resources on trivial matters.

Oh and Blaney my name is Matt Clifford, thought it might make my injunction easier.


About Me

My photo
I am currently in my final year at Winchester University studying Journalism. I hope to become a music journalist although I now realise how difficult it would be to make a living from. Im currently assessing my career options so any suggestions would be welcomed!

Followers

Search This Blog

http://rpc.blogcatalog.com/